The Mistake That Changed Everything

Emily didn’t remember much of her early childhood, but she did remember laughter. Small moments of happiness—like when Margaret would hold her after a nightmare or when Richard lifted her into his arms and spun her around the living room. Those memories were vague, almost like echoes, but they were real. And that was the cruelest part of fate: making her believe she had a family… only to take it away.

Everything changed the day Isabella arrived.

She was fourteen. That autumn, the wind seemed colder than ever. Margaret called her into the living room with a voice that allowed no excuses. When she came down, she found her adoptive parents with tense faces, and beside them, a girl her age with bright eyes and elegant clothes. Alongside them stood a couple of doctors, expressionless, holding a folder.

“There was a mistake at the hospital,” they said. “Fourteen years ago. The girls were switched at birth.”

Emily’s heart stopped. She couldn’t understand. She couldn’t process it. Her hands trembled as the adults spoke of DNA tests, records, a tragedy dating back to the day she was born.

Emily’s biological parents had died in a car accident when she was only weeks old. No one knew them. They had no fortune or notable name. Meanwhile, Isabella had lived all those years with a humble family who, as loving as they were, did not have the status of the Carters.

Margaret cried. Richard frowned deeply. Isabella, on the other hand, smiled. That smile etched itself into Emily’s memory as a warning. It wasn’t kind. It was a smile of triumph.

“From now on, Isabella will live with us,” Richard said without even looking her in the eye. “It’s the right thing to do.”

Emily nodded. She didn’t fully understand what that meant yet, but she would soon.

At first, she tried to adapt. She thought she could share her space, learn to live alongside her. But Isabella soon showed her true colors. In front of the Carters, she was sweet, polite, grateful. But when they were alone, her tone changed.

“You shouldn’t be here,” she whispered one night. “This was my life, not yours. Enjoy it while you can.”

Isabella was clever. She didn’t need to yell or push. It was enough to manipulate situations, make Emily look clumsy or disrespectful. Little by little, Margaret and Richard began to see her differently.

She was no longer “their girl.” She was a burden. A mistake that had lasted fourteen years.

The transformation was slow but relentless.

First, they took away her room. “Isabella deserves the big room,” Margaret said without blinking. Emily was sent to the old service quarters.

Her new room was cramped, cold, and filled with dusty boxes. The wallpaper was peeling, and the single window overlooked the narrow alley behind the house, where trash sometimes blew in the wind.

Emily tried to decorate the room with small things she found — a faded photo, a pressed flower from spring — but nothing could brighten the place. It was a physical reminder of her fall from daughter to servant.

Then, she was no longer invited to family dinners or outings. Her birthdays went unnoticed. Sweet words were replaced by orders.

“Clear the table.”

“Clean the bathrooms.”

“Make sure Isabella has everything ready for tomorrow.”

She was no longer a daughter. She was servitude.

Emily tried to resist. She wanted to speak up, scream, reclaim what had been taken. But she had no one. No one who would listen. No one who believed her.

Sometimes, late at night, she would stand by the window, watching the stars, wishing for something impossible. She didn’t know what that something was, but it was a hope that kept her alive.

School became a temporary refuge. There, though quiet and shy, no one knew what she endured at home. But even there, Isabella’s shadow followed her. One day, without warning, Isabella enrolled in her school.

Comparisons began immediately.

“Why aren’t you more like your sister?” teachers asked. “Isabella participates; she’s brilliant.”

Emily lowered her head. She couldn’t compete. She didn’t want to. She just wanted to disappear.

One afternoon, returning from school, she found her books torn and thrown in the trash.

“They must have fallen,” Isabella said, feigning concern. “You should be more careful.”

Margaret didn’t bother checking. She blamed Emily.

“You’re always making a mess, Emily. Stop playing the victim.”

Over the years, Emily stopped speaking. Not with words, at least. She learned to read glances, avoid arguments, disappear inside her own home. She became an expert at pretending she didn’t feel.

But deep inside, something kept beating. Something they couldn’t extinguish.

When she was eighteen, hiding in the attic, she found an old box with belongings that had once been hers: drawings from when she was a child, letters Margaret had once written with tenderness, photos of past birthdays.

She cried silently that night. Not out of nostalgia, but because she knew none of it belonged to her anymore.

And then, she thought something for the first time that would quietly shape her.

She said nothing out loud, but deep inside her mind, an idea began to take form.

The most obvious change came with her appearance. Without realizing it, she had started to change. At eighteen, her body had matured, her face had softened. Her gentle features, hidden by years of neglect, began to emerge.

But Emily didn’t know it.

She never looked in the mirror. Didn’t wear makeup, didn’t fix her hair. Always wore old clothes, many inherited or patched. Margaret wouldn’t let her have anything like Isabella’s.

“We won’t spend on someone who will soon leave this house,” she said.

Emily didn’t understand what they meant. Until one day she overheard a conversation that froze her blood.

Richard and Margaret spoke quietly in the study, unaware she was nearby, cleaning behind the door.

“We need to find her a husband soon.”

“Who would want her?” Richard snorted. “No name, no education…”

“But she still has youth. With a nice dress and makeup, she doesn’t look bad.”

Emily stepped back. Her legs shook. They were talking about… selling her. Like property.

At twenty, they no longer hid it. Margaret started introducing her to “important men” visiting the house.

“This is Mr. Vargas. He does business with your father.”

“This is Mr. Ortiz. He likes well-educated girls.”

“Smile, Emily. Be polite.”

She felt like an exhibit. She didn’t understand their intentions until she heard another conversation: a marriage deal to improve the Carter family’s position.

And then came the horror: the “chosen one” was a forty-year-old, obese man with a reputation for abusing previous wives. Rich, yes. But cruel. Completely despicable.

Emily wanted to scream. To run. To die.

But she didn’t.

Because deep inside, that small voice was still alive.

She said nothing out loud, but deep inside her mind, an idea began to take form.

Meanwhile, her only refuge was the part-time job at the café. There, at least, she was treated like a person. With respect. Without shouting.

And it was there, at eighteen, that she met Nathan Blake.

He seemed like an ordinary guy. Simple clothes, calm gaze, measured voice. But over time, Emily felt there was something different about him. He didn’t just look at her… he saw her. As if he understood without words.

What Emily didn’t know was that Nathan had been watching her more closely than she imagined. He had noticed her presence from the first time she served him coffee. After months of visits, his interest became concern.

One day, when Emily didn’t show up without warning, Nathan felt an anxiety he couldn’t explain. He sent one of his assistants to investigate quietly. What he found chilled him: Emily’s story, the hospital mistake, her status within the Carter family… everything.

Nathan was many things. Heir to a business empire, brilliant young man, cold to his enemies. But with her… with Emily, he was different.

And though she didn’t know it yet, he had already decided to intervene.

Not because he felt guilty.

Not out of pity.

But because he had chosen her. Long before he understood why.

And so, fate—so cruel until now—began to change its cards.

***Download NovelToon to enjoy a better reading experience!***