The Wrong Daughter

The shriek of the alarm shattered the silence at six in the morning. Emily opened her eyes without flinching. In truth, she hadn’t been asleep. Sleep had long since become a luxury—rare, fragile, fleeting. She sat up in bed, running her fingers along the frayed edge of her blanket as she watched the faint morning light slip through the dust-covered window.

Her room was little more than a converted storage closet. A narrow bed, a rickety chair, and a closet that leaned slightly to the left. The walls were stained with dampness, and in the corner sat a cardboard box filled with secondhand clothes that barely fit. And yet, it was the only place in that huge house she could call her own.

Since she was fourteen, Emily Carter—or so she was called—had ceased to be a daughter and had instead become a sort of silent maid. That was the year Isabella arrived. The real daughter. The hospital's mistake had been discovered, and with it, everything Emily had known crumbled.

“Emily!” Margaret’s voice rang from downstairs. “Get up! We have guests coming at noon! And I don’t want to see a single speck of dust in this house!”

Emily swallowed. She got up without a word, as always, and began her routine: make the bed, mop the floor with an old rag, and slip out of her room quietly.

She paused briefly in front of the hallway mirror. Her reflection stared back with resignation: dull hair, pale skin, worn-out clothes. But beneath that tired image, her eyes held something else. A quiet sadness, yes—but also a strength slowly taking root.

She reached the bottom of the stairs just in time to see Isabella sitting at the dining table, still in her pajamas, eating fresh fruit and laughing softly at her phone. She looked flawless, as always. The perfect daughter.

“Good morning, sister,” Isabella said with a smile that might have seemed kind to anyone else—but Emily knew better.

“Good morning,” Emily replied, not meeting her gaze.

“Don’t speak to her like that!” Richard barked from his armchair. “Isabella has been nothing but kind to you. Learn to be grateful.”

Emily nodded. She no longer tried to defend herself. Words were useless in this house. Margaret tossed her a list of chores: clean the bathrooms, wash the guest linens, prepare the table for lunch. Everything had to be perfect.

As she scrubbed the floor, her mind drifted to the past. She remembered being eight, and Margaret hugging her after a nightmare. She remembered small but heartfelt birthday parties. All of that vanished the day a doctor walked in with a file and a truth that shattered her world: “She is not your daughter.”

Emily’s biological parents had died in a car crash shortly after her birth. The hospital had made an unforgivable mistake—swapping her with Isabella, the Carters’ real daughter.

From that day on, Isabella took her place—not just in the family, but in life itself.

Emily found solace in her part-time job. At seventeen, she’d managed to get hired at a modest café downtown. It wasn’t fancy, but the scent of coffee, the hiss of steam, and the clinking of ceramic cups gave her peace.

That’s where she met him.

Nathan Blake.

The first time she saw him, it was a rainy afternoon. He wore a dark jacket and his hair was damp. He ordered a cappuccino and sat in the farthest corner of the café. He didn’t speak much, didn’t ask questions. He just watched.

Emily served him with the same polite smile she gave everyone, but he looked at her… differently.

Week after week, he returned every Tuesday and Friday. Always sat in the same spot. Sometimes he wrote in a notebook, other times he just stared out the window.

“Do you work here every day?” he asked one afternoon as she brought him his drink.

Emily hesitated. No one ever asked her things like that.

“Most days. Sometimes I switch shifts,” she answered softly.

Nathan nodded. He said nothing more, but he came back the next day. And the one after that.

What she didn’t know was that Nathan wasn’t just any young man. At twenty-three, he was the heir to one of the most powerful corporations in the country. His family owned the conglomerate that controlled the very company Richard Carter worked for.

Nathan, however, had decided to experience life outside the golden bubble. He adopted a common identity, away from investors and media. He liked observing the real world. He liked watching people who were real.

And Emily was, without a doubt, the most real person he had ever seen.

One Saturday night, Emily came home exhausted. The café had been busy all day. When she walked in, she found the living room full of guests. No one offered her a seat. Margaret sent her straight to the kitchen to help with dishes—still in her café uniform.

While scrubbing greasy pans, she could hear Isabella’s voice from the dining room.

“Have you seen the girl who lives with us?” she laughed. “She’s not really family. It’s like… she’s some old houseplant in a corner.”

Laughter. Richard said nothing. Margaret didn’t defend her either.

Emily gritted her teeth, but she didn’t cry. She had stopped crying over things like that. Instead, she thought of Nathan. Of the way he looked at her, the way his words were kind, different. She thought about how his presence made her feel… human.

She wondered if Nathan had ever gone through something similar. Had life failed him, too?

“One day… I’ll leave this place,” she promised herself. “I’ll have my own life. My own home.”

She didn’t know when. She didn’t know how. But something deep inside her was beginning to stir.

The next morning, Nathan showed up earlier than usual.

“Are you okay?” he asked, noticing the dark circles under her eyes.

Emily blinked, surprised. No one ever noticed things like that.

“I’m just tired,” she replied.

Nathan set his coffee down.

“Do you want to sit for a moment?”

She hesitated. Her manager wouldn’t like it. But something in his voice calmed her. She sat down lightly on the chair across from him.

“You don’t have to say anything,” he said, not meeting her eyes. “Just… if you ever need someone to talk to, I’m here.”

Emily felt a lump in her throat. No one had offered her something as simple as company in years.

She nodded, unable to speak. Nathan didn’t press her. He just picked up his cup again and took a sip.

In that moment, something shifted inside her. Maybe she wasn’t entirely alone.

And though she didn’t know it yet, Nathan had already begun to investigate. His instincts told him that this quiet girl had a story far more complicated than she let on. And when he uncovered the truth… he wouldn’t just stand by.

***Download NovelToon to enjoy a better reading experience!***