Truth Beneath the Mirror

After that night , something inside Lilly shifted.

It was subtle at first — not a scream or a spark, just a silent decision, the kind that blooms in the back of the mind and slowly takes root. She stopped trusting what she saw. She started watching everything.

From that night on, Lilly became a student of the twins.

Every word they spoke, every gesture they made, every look exchanged when they thought she wasn’t watching — she noticed them all. She watched how James’ footsteps were heavier when he climbed the stairs,

While Justin’s always paused halfway, as if lost in thought.

She memorized the way James reached for a glass with careless strength, while Justin set it down softly, almost politely. Even the way they breathed when they slept was different — James sighed in short impatient bursts, Justin’s breaths were long and even, like someone used to silence.

And most importantly, she began tracking when each appeared.

When James vanished for “work,” Justin appeared in his place with calmer eyes and gentler words. When Justin had a meeting at his company, James returned with arrogance

Hanging off him like a tailored suit. They thought they were fooling her. They thought the game was flawless.

But Lilly was no longer the same woman.

She wrote everything down — in her mind, in hidden notes — every switch, every slip, every shadow of difference. Day by day, she built a perfect map of the two men’s secret choreography.

And then she went deeper.

It started with curiosity. It turned into an investigation.

In the quiet hours of her hospital shifts, when the city outside dimmed and the hospital corridors smelled faintly of antiseptic and exhaustion, Lilly dug into the pieces of Justin’s life.

She traced back to the university he attended, the old classmates they both once mentioned. And there, in that pile of forgotten stories, the real Justin emerged.

He had always been reserved — the quiet twin who walked beside James but never tried to outrun him. Loyal. Almost painfully so.

She found a few mentions of a childhood crush, an innocent infatuation from his school

Days — but after that, nothing. No girlfriends. No long romances.

No scandals. He had built a small but growing company while still in college, pouring himself into work instead of chasing affection. It was a life carved out of discipline and quiet strength.

James, on the other hand…

He had spent those same years drifting from thrill to thrill — racing cars with friends, flirting his way through parties, and treating commitment like a word meant for other people.

Where Justin built, James burned.

And then there was the truth that twisted the knife deeper: the man who had always been gentle with her… was Justin, not James.

All those small kindnesses she had held close, the tenderness that had convinced her love could soften even James’ roughest edges — they hadn’t been James at all.

The comforting messages on her late shifts, the patient listening when she came home exhausted, the quiet presence when she needed it most — they had all been Justin stepping into James’ role.

James had never been that man. He had never waited for her to return late from the hospital, never brewed her tea when her hands were shaking from exhaustion, never softened his tone when she cried.

James had always been distant, volatile, and quick to Anger. And she had accepted it, telling herself that love was supposed to be imperfect — that she just had to hold on, and he would change.

And she believed he had changed.

Because the man she came home to had changed. He had become patient. Gentle. Thoughtful.

But it wasn’t James. It had never been James.

It was Justin.

The more Lilly uncovered, the more the facade cracked. Piece by piece, the truth bled through the lies James had built around her.

She learned about the woman James had once loved — the one he still visited in the corners of his memory, the one he had never truly let go of.

That ghost lived behind his eyes even now. James hadn’t chosen Lilly out of love; he had chosen her out of ambition.

Because Lilly, the brilliant doctor with discipline and respect in her name, was the perfect partner to complete the picture of the man he wanted to become. She was not the dream — she was the decoration.

He loved someone else. He always had. And Lilly — foolish, hopeful Lilly — had spent years believing she had changed him.

The irony was brutal.

It wasn’t her love that had changed him. It wasn’t James who had changed at all.

It was Justin who had stepped into the empty spaces James left behind, who had offered the warmth James never had, who had kept the illusion alive while James remained the man he had always been — selfish, careless, and incapable of real love.

By the time her investigation ended, Lilly sat alone in the quiet of her apartment, her hands trembling slightly as she stared at the city lights outside.

Every revelation played in her head like a cruel film reel — scenes she had once clung to as proof of love now replayed as proof of deception.

Her heart felt heavier than it ever had.

She loved James with every ounce of herself.

She had built her world around him, believed in him even when the cracks showed, fought for a future she thought they both wanted. And in the end, it had all been a performance — a carefully constructed illusion James had maintained, with Justin’s unknowing help, to keep her anchored.

The betrayal wasn’t just in James’ lies.

It was in the years she had lost to them. The woman she had been — trusting, hopeful, foolish — had died quietly somewhere along the way.

Now, what remained of her was sharper. Colder. And so very tired.

She had already decided that there would be revenge — that James would pay for every moment he made her feel small, for every time he treated her love like a tool, for every smile built on a lie. But even vengeance couldn’t stitch up the tear in her chest.

Because beneath the rage, she was still heartbroken.

Her long relationship — the love she had built brick by brick, day by day — had never truly existed. It was nothing more than a stage James had built to play the role he needed her to believe.

And Lilly, blinded by devotion, had clapped for the performance.

Now she stood at the edge of something new. She was no longer the woman who would swallow lies and call them love. She was no longer the woman who would beg for scraps of affection and convince herself it was enough.

She was the woman who knew the truth.

And knowing the truth meant she could finally decide what to do with it.

The game James had started was far from over.

But this time, Lilly was going to be the one pulling the strings.

***Download NovelToon to enjoy a better reading experience!***