Chapter 5: The Women Underneath

Vivian had lied so many times in her life that the truth no longer fit easily in her mouth. It scraped, it caught on old wounds, it burned going down. But as Jack Callahan stood in the center of her motel room, boots wet, eyes pinned to her like she was a ticking bomb — she didn’t reach for a lie.

She reached for the truth. Slowly. Carefully. Like a blade unsheathed.

“My name…” she began, her voice rough, “...is Eleanor Winters.”

Jack didn’t flinch, not exactly. But something in his face changed — like a puzzle suddenly snapping into place. She could see it in his eyes. The photos. The rumors. The way the whole damn town had buried her name and pretended it never existed.

He took one slow step toward her. “You were the woman in that car.”

She nodded once. “They said it was suicide. Daniel made sure they did.”

Jack looked down, exhaled through his nose. He wasn’t the kind of man who shouted. She imagined even his anger came out in whispers and hard stares.

“I ran my fingers over every file on your case six months ago,” he muttered. “Something about it always stank. But no body, no blood, and a husband too well-connected to touch…”

Vivian crossed her arms. “That’s the beauty of monsters in expensive suits. No one believes they have teeth.”

He looked up at her again — really looked. “You faked your own death?”

“I escaped,” she said. “Barely. I had bruises no one could see and scars no one wanted to talk about. So I stopped waiting to be saved.”

Silence stretched between them like glass — fragile, trembling.

Jack let out a long breath and leaned against the motel’s dresser like it was holding him up. “Jesus, Eleanor. You could’ve told me. I would’ve—”

“You don’t know what you would’ve done,” she cut in, sharper than she meant to. “You seem like a good man, Jack. But good men still get eaten by bad systems. Daniel would’ve buried you right next to me.”

He looked away, jaw tight. She could see it — the war in him. Between duty and instinct. Between justice and the rules.

“I need you to understand something,” she said, softer now. “I didn’t come back to stir up gossip. I came back to tear him down. Everything. Brick by brick. You can walk away now. I won’t blame you.”

But Jack Callahan didn’t move.

Instead, he stepped forward. Slowly. Carefully. Like he was approaching a wounded animal in the dark.

He raised a hand — paused — then gently tucked a stray piece of hair behind her ear. His fingers lingered just a second longer than necessary.

“You don’t scare me, Eleanor,” he said quietly. “But the way you keep trying to carry this alone? That does.”

Vivian’s breath caught in her chest. Because no one had said her real name in five years — not with that much care, that much steadiness. And it broke something loose inside her.

But before either of them could say anything more, her burner phone buzzed from the table.

She picked it up. One message. No sender ID.

“Nice to see you again, darling. Shame if your second act ended like the first.”

Her blood turned to ice.

Daniel knew.

Not just something. He knew. And now it wasn’t just a game. It was war.

Meanwhile…

At the Winters Estate, Daniel Winters stood at his office window, drink untouched in his hand, eyes fixed on the hills.

He hadn’t believed it — not at first. The woman in the Mustang. The way she looked at him. The way her voice slid under his skin like a memory.

But then he’d seen it. The old scar on her left collarbone. Barely visible now, but he remembered it too well. He’d caused it.

“She’s alive,” he said aloud. His voice was hoarse. Hollow.

The man sitting across from him — Ezra Vale, his fixer — didn’t flinch. “Then it’s simple,” Ezra said. “We finish what we started.”

Daniel turned. “No.”

Ezra raised an eyebrow. “You sure about that? Because the minute she opens her mouth, the foundation you’re standing on is going to split.”

Daniel’s hand tightened on the glass until it cracked.

“I’m not afraid of her,” he said.

Ezra gave a small, cold smile. “You should be.”

Back in the motel, Vivian stared at the message, her fingers trembling for the first time in days.

Jack read it over her shoulder, and then without hesitation, took her phone, pulled out the battery, and tossed it in the trash.

“Get your coat,” he said.

“What?”

“You’re not staying here tonight. Not while he’s watching.”

Vivian blinked. “Where would I even—”

“Where I can see you. Where I can keep you safe.”

A pause.

She studied him — his steady presence, his tired eyes, the way he hadn’t run yet. Maybe wouldn’t.

And for the first time since she came back to Willow Creek, Eleanor Winters — not just Vivian Hart, not the woman hellbent on revenge — felt the smallest flicker of something dangerous.

Hope.

***Download NovelToon to enjoy a better reading experience!***