Chapter Ten: Clashing Shadows

(Ariadne Asselina Ildelfonso's POV)

The moment Gavyn started walking toward us, the ambient chatter in the bar seemed to quiet down. Every pair of eyes—whether curious or cautious—turned toward our table. I could feel my pulse quicken, a mix of dread and helplessness swirling in my stomach.

Gavyn’s strides were measured and deliberate, his dark eyes fixed on me, and—inevitably—on Arzhael. The air around us grew charged with tension as if the entire room were holding its breath for the inevitable collision.

Arzhael's hand tightened around mine, and for a brief second, our eyes met. There was no fear there—only a silent promise of solidarity. Then, Gavyn’s presence broke the fragile calm.

“Ah, Ariadne,” Gavyn drawled, his voice a blend of condescension and something dangerously close to amusement. “Drowning your sorrows in solitude, I see?”

I felt the blood drain from my face as I tried to steady my trembling hands. Arzhael's grip on mine provided a fleeting anchor, but it did little to quell the storm of emotions that surged within me.

“Gavyn,” I managed, my voice barely above a whisper, “what are you doing here?”

He stopped at the edge of our table, leaning casually against the back of an adjacent chair. His gaze flicked from me to Arzhael with a sardonic smile playing at his lips. “I could ask you the same, but it seems you’re quite comfortable sharing your pain with a friend.”

Arzhael's eyes flashed, and he shifted slightly in his seat. “And you’re always quick to judge how others choose to spend their evenings,” he retorted dryly. His tone was measured but laced with sarcasm.

Gavyn’s smile widened. “Oh, Arzhael, isn’t it? Always the noble savior, ever ready to rescue our damsel in distress.” His voice dripped with ironic charm. “I suppose you must be proud of your self-appointed role.”

Arzhael’s jaw set, and he leaned forward, his tone equally caustic. “Self-appointed? I prefer to think of it as loyalty. Something you seem to have misplaced long ago.”

The verbal sparring cut through the bar’s muted ambience like a razor’s edge. I sat frozen, caught between their barbed words, feeling as though I were the prize in some twisted contest of wounded pride. Their voices escalated, each sentence a volley aimed directly at the other’s insecurities.

Gavyn chuckled darkly. “Loyalty? Is that what you call clinging to outdated notions of honor? Perhaps you should focus on building something instead of lamenting what once was.”

Arzhael’s eyes narrowed, and he responded, “Maybe I should, if it means not resorting to empty theatrics to cover your regrets. You parade around as if you’re the only one who ever mattered—when in truth, you left nothing but destruction behind.”

I felt a hot surge of humiliation and anger mix within me. How easily they traded barbs, as if our shared past were nothing more than an entertaining anecdote in their ongoing feud. I tried to speak, to interject, but the words caught in my throat.

Gavyn’s gaze swept over me, his tone suddenly softening. “Ariadne, please, don’t let this ruin your night,” he said, though the sarcasm was never fully masked. “You’ve been through enough.”

I shook my head, trying to retreat behind the walls I had so painstakingly built. “I said I’m fine,” I whispered, though every fiber of my being protested the lie.

Arzhael’s hand squeezed mine reassuringly, and he added, “Ariadne, you deserve better than this—better than having your pain be a spectacle.”

Gavyn’s eyes flicked toward Arzhael, and for a long moment, the tension between them seemed to solidify into a tangible barrier. “You’re always so sanctimonious, aren’t you, Arzhael? Do you really believe you can save her from her own past?” he asked, his voice low and cutting.

“Perhaps not,” Arzhael replied coolly, “but at least I try. Unlike some, who seem content to let the past dictate every move.”

Their words swirled around me, each syllable a reminder of the choices I’d made, the betrayals I’d endured. I closed my eyes, trying to shut out the clashing voices as they circled, each accusing and lamenting in equal measure.

Then Gavyn stepped forward once more, his face inches from mine. His eyes bore into mine, softening just enough for me to see a flicker of something—remorse, maybe, or longing—before it was replaced by that same icy determination. “Ariadne,” he murmured, “I never stopped loving you. I never stopped regretting the day I pushed you away.”

I stiffened, a part of me recoiling at the sound of his confession, while another part—so deeply buried—stirred with reluctant recognition. “You betrayed me,” I spat, my voice trembling between anger and sorrow. “You left me to drown in my own misery.”

Gavyn’s expression hardened. “Yes, I did. And I have lived with that every day since. But can you honestly say that forgetting isn’t the same as forgiving? I was lost, and I was wrong.”

Before Arzhael could interject, Gavyn continued, “I’ve come back not to reignite the flames of the past, but to offer you a chance—a second chance—to decide what you really want.”

The words hung in the air, heavy and dissonant. Arzhael’s eyes flickered with a mix of contempt and concern as he leaned forward. “And what exactly do you expect her to decide? To let you waltz back in and erase all the pain you caused?” His tone was bitter, his gaze never leaving Gavyn’s.

Gavyn’s smirk returned, but it was laced with a note of desperation. “No,” he said softly, “I expect nothing less than your truth. I expect you to decide what’s best for you. And if that means acknowledging that part of you still loves me—if you can even look past the scars—then so be it.”

I sat between them, feeling the weight of their words press down on me. The past and the present collided in a painful, inescapable vortex, and I was left suspended in the middle, struggling to find a way out.

“Enough,” I finally managed, my voice raw and unsteady. “This isn’t a contest between you two. It’s my life—my heart—being torn apart all over again.”

A hush fell over the table. For a moment, the sarcasm, the barbed words, all the rancor evaporated, leaving only the raw, aching truth.

Gavyn’s gaze softened further, but Arzhael's eyes remained guarded. “Ariadne, I…” Gavyn began, but the words caught in his throat.

Arzhael's voice broke the silence, firm yet gentle. “We’re both here because we care, in our own ways. But you have to choose—not between us, but for yourself. You can’t keep living in the shadow of what you once were.”

I took a deep, shuddering breath. “I’m tired,” I admitted. “Tired of fighting, of being torn between what I want and what I deserve.”

Gavyn reached out slowly, his hand hovering near mine as if he were asking permission. “I’m not asking for forgiveness,” he said quietly, “but I’m asking for a chance to show you that I can be different. That I can be the man you once believed in.”

My eyes welled up, not entirely from the whiskey, but from the flood of emotions that I had long kept at bay. “I don’t know if I can,” I whispered, feeling the vulnerability of it all.

Arzhael's hand closed around mine, steady and comforting. “Maybe you don’t have to decide right now,” he offered softly. “Just know that you deserve peace. Not this endless conflict between past regrets and present uncertainties.”

For a long, agonizing moment, the three of us sat in charged silence. The bar around us seemed to blur into insignificance as I wrestled with the raw ache of old wounds and the possibility of new beginnings. The voices of Gavyn and Arzhael—their sarcasm, their barbs, their hidden care—merged into a cacophony that echoed the dissonance in my heart.

Then, with a final, resigned sigh, I rose from my stool. “I need to get out of here,” I said, my voice trembling with both exhaustion and resolve.

Gavyn and Arzhael exchanged one last look—a mixture of rivalry, regret, and something that might have been hope. “I’ll walk you out,” Arzhael offered firmly.

I hesitated, torn between the two, before nodding silently. As we stepped out of the bar, the cool night air hit me like a wave, washing away some of the oppressive tension. But the memory of that confrontation, the raw vulnerability of our words, clung to me.

Outside, under the flickering neon sign, I paused. I wasn’t sure what tomorrow would bring, or if the ghosts of the past would continue to haunt me. All I knew was that I was at a crossroads—torn between the lingering allure of a love that had once been, and the promise of a future that demanded I heal.

Gavyn stood a few paces away, his eyes dark and unreadable. Arzhael stayed close, his steady presence a silent reminder that I wasn’t alone, even when the past tried to overtake me.

“Whatever you decide,” Arzhael said softly, “just make sure it’s for you.”

I nodded, unable to speak. The night had been long, filled with clashing shadows and fractured lines, and now, as the city’s heartbeat pulsed around us, I realized that my journey toward healing would be anything but simple.

In that moment, standing on the cold pavement with two men representing all that was both broken and hopeful in my life, I made a silent promise: I would no longer let the past define me. I would confront the scars, however painful, and find a way to forge a new path—a path where I could finally choose peace over endless conflict.

But as I looked up, I saw Gavyn’s gaze lingering on me, a challenge unspoken in his eyes. And I wondered, not for the first time, if some wounds were meant to remain, their memory a constant reminder that love, in all its beauty and brutality, was never truly lost.

With the night stretching out before us and the promise of dawn yet to come, I stepped away into the darkness, carrying with me the heavy burden of my fractured heart and the hope that, one day, I might learn to mend it—piece by painful piece.

***Download NovelToon to enjoy a better reading experience!***