Chapter 3: Crossroads

The heat of July settled over Riverbend like a heavy blanket, the kind that left the air thick and the days long. Naomi spent more time by the river now, seeking relief from the weight of her emotions as much as from the oppressive summer sun. Every day that passed brought her closer to the inevitable moment when she would have to make a choice, and yet the more she tried to figure it out, the more tangled her feelings became.

Asher and Copper had both slipped into her life in ways she never expected, and now they were as much a part of her summer as the river itself. But the easy rhythm she had once found with them was now replaced by an undercurrent of tension that she couldn’t ignore. It was like the calm before a storm, and Naomi could feel it building, day by day.

---

It was a lazy afternoon when Naomi found herself back at the Smith family’s farm. Asher had invited her over, promising to show her the latest addition to their stable — a new colt born just a few days earlier.

The farm had always been a place of comfort for Naomi, with its wide open fields and the distant sound of horses whinnying. She had spent many afternoons here with Asher, helping with chores or just lounging in the sun while he told her stories about growing up in Riverbend. It was easy to forget her worries when she was with him, to get lost in the lightness he brought into her life.

But today, as she walked through the barn with him, something felt different. There was a weight in the air, a sense that things were shifting beneath the surface.

Asher led her to the stall where the colt was resting beside its mother, a sleek mare with a glossy black coat. The colt was small, still a little unsteady on its legs, but its eyes were wide and curious, full of life.

"Isn’t he something?" Asher said, leaning against the stall door with a grin. "We haven’t named him yet, but I’m thinking something strong. Like Thunder or Blaze."

Naomi smiled, reaching out to gently stroke the colt’s nose. "He’s beautiful."

Asher watched her for a moment, his blue eyes softening. "You’ve got a way with them, you know. The horses. They like you."

She shrugged, trying to brush off the compliment. "I think they just know I’m not a threat."

"Maybe," Asher said, his voice lowering. "Or maybe they can tell you’re something special."

Naomi froze at his words, her hand still resting on the colt’s nose. When she looked up at Asher, his expression was serious, more serious than she had ever seen him.

"Asher—"

"I’ve been thinking about us," he interrupted, stepping closer to her. "About this summer, and how everything’s changed since you came here."

Her heart began to race, and Naomi could feel the conversation veering into territory she wasn’t ready for. She wasn’t sure she could handle this right now, not with everything still so uncertain.

"I don’t want to pressure you," Asher continued, his voice soft but earnest. "But I like you, Naomi. I’ve liked you from the start, and I just… I need to know if you feel the same."

There it was. The question she had been dreading, the one she knew would eventually come but had been trying to avoid. She felt her chest tighten, the weight of his words settling over her like a cloud.

"Asher, I—" She faltered, searching for the right words. How could she explain the mess of feelings swirling inside her? How could she tell him that she liked him too, but that she couldn’t shake the feelings she had for Copper?

As if summoned by her thoughts, Copper appeared at the entrance to the barn, his tall frame silhouetted against the bright sunlight. He hesitated when he saw them, his eyes flicking from Naomi to Asher, and Naomi’s heart sank. She could feel the tension between the brothers like a living thing, crackling in the air between them.

Copper’s gaze locked onto hers, and for a moment, the world seemed to stop. She saw the question in his eyes, the same unspoken question that had lingered between them since the day they first met. He hadn’t pushed her, hadn’t asked for anything more than what she was willing to give, but she could see now that he was waiting, just as Asher was.

Naomi stood there, caught between them, her heart racing as the weight of the moment pressed down on her. She could feel her pulse in her throat, could hear the rustling of the horses in the barn, the distant sound of wind through the trees. It was like the whole world was holding its breath, waiting for her to speak.

Asher looked between her and his brother, his brow furrowing in confusion. "What’s going on here?"

Naomi took a deep breath, the words tangled in her throat. She didn’t know how to explain what she was feeling, didn’t know how to put into words the pull she felt toward both of them.

"I—" she started, her voice shaking. "I don’t know."

Asher’s face fell, the light in his eyes dimming as he stepped back. "You don’t know?"

"I didn’t mean for this to happen," Naomi said quickly, her heart aching at the hurt she saw in his expression. "I didn’t mean to—"

"To what?" Asher asked, his voice rising. "To lead us both on? To play us against each other?"

Naomi recoiled at the accusation, the sting of his words cutting deep. "That’s not fair," she said, her voice trembling. "I never wanted to hurt either of you."

"But you did," Asher shot back, his eyes flashing with anger. "You’ve been stringing us along all summer, and now you’re telling me you don’t even know how you feel?"

Naomi opened her mouth to respond, but the words wouldn’t come. She looked at Copper, silently pleading for help, but his expression was unreadable. He had always been the more guarded of the two, but now he seemed even more distant, like he was shutting himself off from whatever was happening.

"Say something," Naomi whispered, her voice breaking. "Please."

But Copper remained silent, his stormy eyes fixed on the ground. The silence stretched between them, heavy and suffocating, and Naomi felt like she was drowning in it.

Asher shook his head, stepping away from both of them. "I thought you were different, Naomi. I thought you were honest."

"I am," Naomi insisted, her voice barely a whisper. "I just—"

"You just don’t know how to choose," Asher finished for her, his voice bitter. "I get it."

Naomi felt tears sting her eyes, but she refused to let them fall. She didn’t want to hurt Asher, didn’t want to hurt either of them, but no matter what she did, it seemed like there was no way out of this without someone getting hurt.

"Asher, wait—" she started, but he was already walking away, his shoulders tense with anger.

Naomi stood frozen in place, watching him go, the pain in her chest nearly unbearable. She turned to Copper, hoping for some kind of comfort, but his expression was still unreadable, his eyes distant.

"I didn’t mean for this to happen," she said softly, her voice trembling.

Copper finally looked up, his gaze locking onto hers. There was no anger in his eyes, no judgment, but there was something else — something deeper, something that made Naomi’s heart ache even more.

"I know," he said quietly. "But it did."

Naomi swallowed hard, the lump in her throat growing larger by the second. She had never felt so lost, so unsure of what to do. She had come to Riverbend looking for peace, for a chance to escape the pressures of her life back home, but instead, she had found herself at the center of a storm she couldn’t control.

And now, standing there in the barn with Copper, with the memory of Asher’s anger still fresh in her mind, she realized that no matter what choice she made, nothing would ever be the same again.

---

Later that evening, Naomi sat by the river, the sun sinking low in the sky and casting the water in shades of orange and gold. The stillness of the scene should have calmed her, but her mind was too restless. Her heart was torn, and the weight of it felt unbearable.

She thought of Asher, his easy smile and the way he had made her laugh so many times. She thought of Copper, his steady presence and the way his quiet strength had drawn her in from the start. They were both so different, and yet she felt connected to each of them in ways she couldn’t explain.

But now, the decision loomed over her, unavoidable.

As the first stars began to blink into the sky, Naomi closed her eyes and let the sounds of the river fill her ears. She didn’t know what tomorrow would bring, but she knew one thing for certain: no matter which path she chose, her heart would never be the same.

---

End of Chapter 3

***Download NovelToon to enjoy a better reading experience!***